A little cold. A lot of freedom.CONTAINS AFFILIATE LINKS · THE NETHERLANDS
WinterFietsPleinWINTER CYCLING ESSENTIALS
EN/NL/BE/DE
STAY DRY

Cycling Overshoes for Normal Shoes and Flat Pedals: How to Choose

Updated · 6 min read · How we research

Affiliate links: this guide links to retailers. If you buy through one of these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we recommend.

Ready to shop? Start with the quick picks below.

Quick picks

Chosen from manufacturer specs and published sources. We haven't tested these ourselves. How we choose →

  1. Good for Everyday shoes in cold rain, down to -5 °C

    AGU Winter Regen Bike Boots Commuter

    AGU lists them as windproof and waterproof with a brushed inside, an insulating liner, a rear zip with water-repellent teeth, a hook-and-loop strap and a -5 to 15 °C range.

    See prices at bol.com
  2. Good for Wet days when you want a snug, zipless cover

    AGU Regenbestendig Overschoenen (Rainproof)

    AGU describes recycled PU stretch fleece with taped seams, no zip, a hook-and-loop strap under the shoe and reflective details, in sizes S to XXXL.

    See prices at bol.com

Also worth a look: AGU Reflection korte bike boots essential, good for short city rides in mild, wet weather; AGU Foul Weather Overschoenen, good for long, cold rides when you want shins and calves covered

Before you order: check the maker's size chart against your shoe size, and size up if you wear thick winter boots.

Links open the retailer's search results in a new tab. Most Dutch shops are in Dutch, so we fill in the search for you.

Your front wheel throws spray at your shoes before anything else on you gets wet, and a wet shoe stays wet all day. If you ride in ordinary shoes on flat pedals, overshoes are a small purchase that keeps the rest of the day comfortable. Most guides assume clip-in road shoes, so this one starts from sneakers and boots.

Do you need overshoes for everyday shoes?

If you ride more than a few minutes in rain or cold, yes. ANWB's advice for very wet weather is to wear well-fitting rain covers over your shoes, and its rain guide simply says to wear overshoes. AGU puts the temperature line at 5 °C and below.

Dry feet matter for warmth as well. ANWB notes that sweat and moisture from outside cool your feet quickly, and recommends thermal socks and shoes that do not fit tightly. A pair of waterproof overshoes over your usual shoes covers the water part. The cold part needs thicker socks or a lined cover. Our rain guide covers the full rain kit, and this page goes deep on the feet.

Neoprene, waterproof fabric or fleece: which material?

Match the material to the weather you ride in most. Thin waterproof fabric suits mild rain, lined or neoprene covers suit frost. The table compares four lines from one brand, AGU. They are examples from one range, not a survey of the market, and the figures are AGU's own descriptions.

Model Material (per AGU) Closure Listed range Cut
Reflection short bike boots 100% polyester, waterproof and windproof Hook-and-loop and snap buttons 5 to 25 °C Low
Rainproof overschoenen Recycled PU stretch fleece, taped seams No zip, strap under the shoe Wetter months Ankle
Winter Regen Bike Boots Commuter Polyester, Kevlar and polyamide, brushed inside, insulating liner Rear zip and strap -5 to 15 °C Ankle
Foul Weather overschoenen 4 mm neoprene, taped seams Not stated Not stated Knee-high

AGU developed the Foul Weather covers for winter road training, so they are a long, warm option rather than a commuter classic. If you want shins and calves covered on a long cold ride, they are the one in this group that does it. The Rainproof covers list the road bike as their discipline, which tells you they are a sporty cut; they still go over normal shoes.

How do overshoes fit over trainers, boots and flat pedals?

Choose by your shoe size and read the chart. AGU sizes the Rainproof covers from S (shoe size under 40) through M (40/41), L (42/43), XL (44/45) and XXL (46/47) to XXXL (47 and up), and the Winter Regen Bike Boots Commuter from S (37-38) to XXL (45-46). If you wear chunky winter boots or high-top trainers, our reasoning is to go one size up, because a cover that has to stretch over the shoe pulls on the seams.

Closure is a matter of habit. A rear zip with a strap, as on the commuter boots, is easier to open wide for boots. A zipless cover with a strap under the shoe, as on the Rainproof, sits snugger around the ankle, which keeps trouser hems from catching. Try pulling them on with gloves on in the shop or the hallway.

Flat pedals bring one practical point. The sole of the cover is the part that touches the pedal, and pedals with pins can chew a thin sole. AGU reinforces soles with faux leather and toes with Kevlar on its range, which is why we would look for those details. Thin covers also wear quickly if you walk in them: AGU lists the Reflection short boots as less suitable for walking.

Should rain trousers go over or under the overshoes?

Over, in our reasoning: the trouser leg then sheds water down onto the cover and away from the shoe. Our guide to winter cycling trousers covers the trouser side. Some trousers solve this in one piece: AGU's Winter Regenbroek Commuter and Compact Regenbroek Commuter both come with pre-shaped shoe covers attached, so you pull one garment over your shoes.

When are waterproof socks or boots a better answer?

Choose waterproof socks or boots if you walk a lot at either end of the ride, or if you hate fiddling with covers. Sealskinz says water can still enter in extreme conditions through the top of a waterproof sock, and its Hydrostop band exists to limit that. Socks do not protect your trouser hem or the upper of your shoes, and they will not stop spray from soaking canvas sneakers.

For most commuters we would start with overshoes, because they go over whatever you wear that day and fold into a bag. Waterproof boots are the neater answer if you already own a pair and wear them every day.

Can overshoes help you be seen?

Yes, because feet move. AGU points out that hands and feet stand out while you cycle and recommends a reflective overshoe so drivers notice you sooner. Look for a reflective print or side stripes, as on AGU's Reflection short boots and the Foul Weather covers. The idea is explained in our guide to reflective gear for cyclists, and lights still do the main work: see bike lights in the Netherlands.

How do you keep your feet warm as well as dry?

Add the warmth in layers inside. ANWB suggests winter-weather or thermal socks, shoes and socks that are not tight, and a foot warmer you stick under the sock, which it says gives off warmth for up to six hours. A neoprene or lined cover helps against wind, but a snug cover over a tight shoe leaves no air to insulate. The winter cycling clothing guide shows how the foot layer fits into the rest of the outfit, and the full winter kit list puts it in order.

How long do overshoes last, and when do you replace them?

No lifetime figure is published, so go by what you can see. Replace them when the seams start to leak, the strap stops holding or the sole has worn through. Those are also the spots AGU reinforces, with faux leather on the sole and Kevlar on the toe. The more you walk in them, the sooner you will notice. Rinse off mud and let them air-dry, since a wet cover stuffed in a bag rarely improves.

What should you buy first?

Start with a single pair of waterproof covers sized to your commuting shoes, and leave the neoprene for the weeks your toes actually go numb. Put them by the front door so they are the first thing you grab on a wet morning.

Frequently asked questions

Do overshoes fit over normal shoes and trainers?

Yes, if you pick the size by your shoe size. AGU's overshoe range runs from S (shoe size under 40) to XXXL (47 and up), and its commuter boots are sized in two-number steps such as 39-40. Thick winter boots may need the next size up, so check the chart before ordering.

Can I use cycling overshoes on flat pedals?

Yes. Several commuter models close with a hook-and-loop strap and carry a reinforced sole, which is what flat pedals and walking wear down first. AGU rates its Reflection short boots as less suitable for walking, so take them off when you leave the bike for longer.

At what temperature do you need overshoes?

For rain, any temperature where wet shoes bother you. AGU advises overshoes at 5 °C and below. Its Winter Regen Bike Boots Commuter are listed from -5 to 15 °C, while the thin Reflection short boots are listed for 5 to 25 °C. Those are manufacturer ranges, not tests.

Are waterproof socks better than overshoes?

They solve different problems. Sealskinz says water can still enter at the top of a waterproof sock in extreme conditions, and ordinary rain trousers can run water down the leg and into a low cover. Overshoes keep the whole shoe and trouser hem dry; socks help when you walk a lot.

How often should overshoes be replaced?

No lifetime figure is published, so go by what you can see. Replace them when the seams leak, the strap stops holding or the sole has worn through. AGU reinforces soles with faux leather and toes with Kevlar on its range, which is where wear tends to show first.

Sources

  1. AGU: Overschoenen
  2. AGU: Winter Regen Bike Boots Commuter
  3. AGU: Zichtbaar en veilig op de fiets
  4. ANWB: Zo blijf je warm en droog op de fiets
  5. ANWB: Fietsen in de regen
  6. Sealskinz: Product information and care
BEFORE YOU UNLOCK THE BIKE

Six quick checks for your lights, tyres, brakes and you. Tick them off on your phone at the door.

Open the checklist
NEWSLETTER

Get winter-ready by email

Three short emails to get you winter-ready, then a note now and then while the cold lasts. Unsubscribe anytime.

We send the newsletter with MailerLite. See our privacy policy.